Two chatbot robots on glowing platforms facing each other with a VS badge between them, one blue and one green, surrounded by workflow, settings, data, code and automation icons, comparing Einstein Bots and Agentforce
Blogs

Agentforce Chatbot: How It Compares to Einstein Bots

Contact Us
Mirketa16 min read

Introduction: Being a Salesforce developer myself, I know that building an appropriate chatbot is not as simple as displaying a welcome message and answering a couple of common questions. A functional chatbot needs to be able to identify the intent of the user, pull out the correct information, perform necessary actions, and know when to route the conversation to a human agent.

For a while now, Einstein Bots has been a preferred option for Salesforce developers for building chatbots to automate conversation with customers. They allow businesses to simplify and scale the interaction with their clients, guiding them through the most common conversation paths.

However, with the recent introduction of Agentforce, Salesforce users are presented with an innovative way of building chatbots that can go beyond rigid predefined paths and engage users in a conversation that uses generative AI and business logic to fulfill their requests.

The obvious question that Salesforce developers face is: should they continue with Einstein Bots or migrate to Agentforce?

What Is an Agentforce Chatbot?

An Agentforce chatbot refers to a conversational bot built using Salesforce Agentforce . This chatbot platform allows users to communicate with an AI agent using natural language and accomplish a set of predefined tasks by leveraging topics, instructions, and actions guided by business logic.

An intriguing characteristic of Agentforce chatbots from a developer’s perspective is that the conversation does not necessarily follow a single predefined flow.

For instance, if I call any healthcare organization and tell them that I want to check my appointment status and reschedule it if the doctor is not available, a traditional chatbot would not be able to fulfill both of these requests without first asking me to clarify one request, obtaining the relevant information, and possibly transferring the call to a human agent.

On the other hand, an appropriately configured Agentforce agent would be able to recognize my request, use predefined actions to obtain information about my appointment, and possibly help me to reschedule it if available.

The actual result would depend on the actions available to the agent, the information that it can retrieve, and the permissions that it has been granted. The agent would not have access to all Salesforce records and operations by default.

From a Salesforce developer’s perspective, Agentforce chatbots can be extremely useful in scenarios where the conversation needs to drive a business process.

What Are Einstein Bots?

Einstein bots are chatbot solutions from Salesforce that allow companies to design chatbots to communicate with customers and employees. Such chatbots can be integrated into the company’s service processes to reply to questions, request information, and follow predefined dialogues.

Einstein bots are most appropriate to use in situations when there is a specific business process that the bot must enforce.

For example, a support bot could be designed to first reply to the customer, explain the situation, ask for the order number, find the necessary details, and either reply directly or forward the conversation to an operator. This could be achieved by designing the conversation tree, declaring the variables, rules, and other elements necessary for the bot to function.

The primary advantage of such a solution is that it is often relatively easy to implement a proof-of-concept solution and be sure that the bot will handle some repetitive tasks. Moreover, if the conversation is designed as a series of predefined actions, it is also relatively easy to ensure that the conversation will be compliant with the business logic and only allow certain actions to take place.

At the same time, the moment a conversation requires multiple steps and branching, such a chatbot may not be able to handle the increased complexity and flexibility of the conversation, especially when trying to address different edge cases and questions that were not anticipated during the design.

Einstein Bots vs Agentforce: Key Differences

When looking at the differences between Einstein Bots and Agentforce, it becomes apparent that the two solutions are aimed at solving different problems.

Einstein BotsAgentforce
Core approachPredefined conversation paths with configurable variablesGenerative AI-driven conversations driven by instructions and actions
Conversation flowGenerally follows defined conversation pathsCan change the conversation flow based on the user request or available actions
Language recognitionFollows predefined intents and languagesUnderstands the request using generative AI and natural language processing
Business actionsExecutes predefined integrations or processesExecutes supported actions, including Flow and Apex operations
Complex requestsMay need additional paths and logicCan address more complex requests
Developer controlRelatively straightforward to define intents and conversation pathsNeeds additional configuration, access control, grounding, and testing
Use caseBest for structured FAQs and repeated processesBest for context-aware assistance and complex conversations

It should be noted that this does not mean that Einstein Bots cannot carry out complex operations, or the chatbots Agentforce have a better understanding of natural language. Both solutions to a certain extent have their strengths and weaknesses, which must be considered when choosing one or the other.

1. Conversation Flow: Predefined Paths vs Flexible Interactions

One of the most apparent differences between an Agentforce chatbot and Einstein Bots is the conversation flow.

With Einstein Bots, the conversation generally follows a specific predefined path. As a developer, it is my responsibility to define the conversation with the user, ask them the right questions at the right moment, and execute the necessary operations to address their request.

For instance, a password-reset chatbot would typically ask the user to select the “I need to reset my password” option and would ask for additional information, such as the username. Once the user specifies their request, the chatbot will be able to execute the predefined sequence of steps to help the user reset their password.

Meanwhile, when building the same solution with Agentforce, a user would be able to type out their request in natural language. If I said that I need to reset my password and update my email address, a well-configured Agentforce chatbot would be able to identify that I have two requests and either execute them or ask me for more information if it does not have enough information to execute them.

As a Salesforce developer, I would have to make sure that the agent has access to the necessary information and tools to fulfill the request. However, I would not necessarily configure the chatbot to ask me to clarify the nature of my request. It would be able to perform this action if it had sufficient permissions, but I would not risk allowing a production-grade Salesforce chatbot to customize the conversation flow.

My takeaway is that Einstein Bots are likely to fulfill simple requests while being less effective at accomplishing complex tasks, and Agentforce chatbots are more versatile and customizable and can be utilized to perform complex actions.

2. Integration With Salesforce Data and Business Logic

One of the main advantages of using a chatbot is the ability to perform tasks within an open-ended conversation.

Both Agentforce and Einstein Bots can be integrated into Salesforce to perform a variety of actions such as accessing and updating records, executing business processes, and completing tasks for the user. The main difference between the two solutions is that Einstein Bots typically rely on predefined integrations, while Agentforce chatbots can execute a variety of actions.

As a Salesforce developer; I would implement such chatbot similarly for both solutions.

For example, if a user inquiries about the status of their service request, I will use Salesforce objects to store the relevant case and customer information. If none of the standard Salesforce features are appropriate for the use case, I would develop additional Apex logic or leverage Flow to accomplish the required task. Furthermore, I would ensure that only the appropriate records and information are shared with the chatbot, which would depend on the user’s permissions.

When implementing the chatbot itself, I would define the conversation the user would have with the chatbot in a similar manner for both solutions. For Einstein Bots, I would define the conversation steps and the information that the chatbot would need to collect to execute the required action.

For Agentforce, I would define the topic and specify the actions that the agent would need to take to execute the task. If retrieving the service request requires additional information from the user, I would configure the agent to ask for the relevant details.

For instance, I could specify an Apex action that would be responsible for fetching the service request based on the provided case number and the user’s permissions. The agent would then use this action to fulfill the user’s request.

I hope this illustrates that Agentforce chatbots are not necessarily better at retrieving data from Salesforce. They provide an additional development path that I, as a Salesforce developer, can use to accomplish the task at hand.

3. Handling Complex Customer Requests

Let’s say that I contacted a company and say that my last invoice seems to be wrong. I would like you to explain the details of the invoice and help me raise a support request to resolve this situation. An Einstein Bot would be able to address this request if I was able to design the conversation flow, give the information I had to offer, and the right questions to ask to identify the problem. However, the chatbot will become significantly more complicated if I started adding additional details or changed the nature of my request.

An Agentforce chatbot, on the other hand, would be able to better follow my instructions, use available actions to provide the relevant information about the invoice, and raise a support request when I ask it to do so, provided that it has the necessary permissions.

When developing such a chatbot, I would need to:

  1. Define the topic of the conversation (invoices).
  2. Specify the instructions (provide the details of the relevant invoice, help raise a support request).
  3. Configure the necessary actions (fetch invoice details, raise support request).
  4. Ensure that the appropriate flows, Apex classes, or Salesforce processes are used when relevant.
  5. Add additional validations and permissions where necessary.
  6. Test the chatbot with different user inputs to ensure that it behaves appropriately.

This does not mean that Agentforce chatbots are inherently better at accomplishing complex tasks. It means that I would need to invest more effort into developing the chatbot so that it could better understand my request and have the right permissions to accomplish the task.

For requests that require complex calculations or validations, especially in financial or other regulated domains, I would not entrust an Agentforce chatbot directly manipulating the data. Instead, I would configure the chatbot to use a business process that would use Apex or Flow to perform the required calculation or validation.

4. Development Experience: What Changes for Salesforce Developers?

As a Salesforce developer, I am used to building Einstein Bots by defining the conversation flow and making sure that the chatbot would be able to accomplish the required task by asking the right questions at the right time.

When building an Agentforce chatbot, my responsibilities are generally similar, but I need to put more effort into ensuring that the agent can accomplish the task.

In other words, I need to think of ways in which the agent can help the user rather than the other way around. This generally means:

  • Defining the topics and instructions that would allow the agent to assist the user
  • Designing the agent’s capabilities by specifying the actions that it can take
  • Connecting the agent to the appropriate data and processes
  • Ensuring that the agent has the appropriate permissions to take any actions
  • Specifying the necessary validation and confirmation steps
  • Testing that the agent would behave as expected with different user inputs
  • Monitoring and optimizing the agent’s performance

When building more complex chatbots, I would utilize Apex to implement specific business logic or Flow to help orchestrate the conversation. This way, I could ensure that the chatbot would be able to fulfill the user’s request in a reliable and consistent manner.

For instance, if the user needed to submit a request to the finance department using a standard form, I would design an appropriate Apex-based action that would let me accomplish the task. I would use LWC to build a custom interface, but when the user interacts with the chatbot, I would rely on the power of Agentforce to fulfill the request. This way, the user experience would be tailored to the needs of the user, while the business logic would remain reliable and well tested.

5. Security and Reliability: An Important Difference in Implementation

A common mistake that I see Salesforce developers making when building chatbots is assuming that an AI-powered solution is inherently secure simply because it runs on the Salesforce platform.

When designing a chatbot, especially one that uses Agentforce, I need to take extra precautions to ensure that my implementation would adhere to the appropriate Salesforce security practices.

I need to consider:

  • What data does the agent need to be able to retrieve to accomplish the task?
  • Does the agent need to be able to update any records, and if so, which fields can it modify?
  • Are there any security constraints that I need to be aware of?

For instance, an agent that helps users schedule an appointment should not be able to update the records of other patients simply because it can update the records of the current user.

Similarly, an agent that helps raise a support request should not be able to update any records without the intervention of a human agent. My implementation checklist would generally include the following security-related items:

  • Enforcing the appropriate field-level, record-level, and object-level security
  • Validating user input and identifiers before using them to query or update records
  • Limiting the agent’s capabilities to only what is necessary to accomplish the task
  • Applying deterministic checks when it comes to business logic
  • Using user confirmation when it comes to sensitive or non-deterministic operations
  • Testing that these security measures are in place

These considerations are particularly vital in regulated industries such as healthcare, or finance, where there are additional requirements that I would have to consider. For instance, I may have to make sure that the agent can only be able to update certain fields, or that any changes to a record would require additional user confirmation.

6. When Should You Choose Einstein Bots?

I hope that this discussion illustrates why Einstein Bots are a viable option for many Salesforce implementations. I would choose Einstein Bots if:

The process is predictable. If the user has to perform a certain set of actions to fix the problem, the most viable solution is to use a chatbot with a limited set of dialogue options.

The conversation has to be heavily guided. There are times when I must force the chatbot to obey strict instructions, ask for specific information in a particular format, and only allow certain operations.

The existing implementation works well. There is no point in migrating to Agentforce simply because it is a new and exciting technology. If my existing implementation fulfills the requirements and is easy to maintain, I should be happy with my solution.

The use case seems simple enough: if your chatbot's only purpose is to answer a few basic questions, collect some information from the user, or forward the conversation to the right team, creating an Einstein Bot may be considerably cheaper.

7. When Should You Choose Agentforce?

I will consider using Agentforce if the business requires building a more flexible solution that can better handle multiple steps and help the user navigate the business process.

Use cases for Agentforce include:

Context-aware customer support. In many cases, users need to ask multiple questions and provide additional information before being able to accomplish their tasks. A context-aware chatbot can help guide the user through the process.

Employee assistance. In some cases, employees need assistance finding the right information or following the appropriate business processes. An agent-driven chatbot can help them accomplish their tasks.

Multi-step business processes. Some processes require multiple steps or actions before they can be completed. Such a process can be accomplished much faster with an appropriately configured Agentforce chatbot.

Conversational access to business data. In some cases, users simply want to be able to access and update business data without going through a series of pages. An appropriately configured Agentforce chatbot can help them accomplish this task.

For instance, an appropriately configured Agentforce chatbot can help an authorized healthcare professional find an appropriate appointment, retrieve the required information, and update the relevant records. However, the said agent will not be able to update the patient's records without additional input or permission from the user.

Furthermore, it must follow the appropriate clinical decision-making protocol and cannot make unsubstantiated medical decisions.

The goal of such a chatbot is not to provide the agent with unlimited power but to make existing business processes easier to follow.

8. Should You Migrate from Einstein Bots to Agentforce?

To make the right choice, I would analyze the existing chatbot and identify the most common pain points.

I would ask myself the following questions:

  • Do users routinely miss opportunities to follow the predefined conversation path?
  • Are we supporting too many different conversation paths?
  • Do customers routinely have to combine multiple requests in a single conversation?
  • Would a more natural conversation experience benefit the users?
  • Can we reuse existing business processes by utilizing Agentforce actions?
  • Are the security, licensing, integration, and maintenance requirements acceptable?

If the existing Einstein Bot accomplishes a few common tasks, I would consider leaving it as is. Meanwhile, if the users routinely struggle to follow the predefined conversation path and the business requires more flexibility, I will consider migrating to Agentforce.

I would start with proof of concept and try to implement a single business process in Agentforce and compare the results against the existing solution. I would consider a variety of metrics, including task completion rate, accuracy, conversation length, frequency of human handoff, quality of response, user experience, and cost-effectiveness.

Conclusion

The discussion about Einstein Bots vs Agentforce is not a discussion about an old solution and an innovative newcomer. It is a discussion about the different ways in which businesses can automate conversations with their clients.

Einstein Bots continues to be a viable option for automating conversations with customers. Agentforce offers a compelling alternative that can be utilized in scenarios that call for greater flexibility.

As a Salesforce developer, I would make the decision based on a combination of factors, including the implementation complexity, required level of control, and user experience.

For some business owners, that may mean sticking with Einstein Bots for now. For others, it may mean experimenting with Agentforce or gradually migrating some of their chatbots to this new platform.

Finally, my advice to Salesforce developers, who have to make a choice between Einstein Bots and Agentforce, would be to consider their particular needs. If the requirements imply designing a complex business logic, which would guide the user through the process, the choice should be made in favor of Agentforce.

On the contrary, if the process can be simplified to a few predefined steps, Einstein Bots would be a great choice. Yet, developers should be aware that Einstein Bots might require extra programming to satisfy specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Get Started

Have Questions? Let's Talk

Share a few details about your goals: a Mirketa consultant will follow up within one business day.

  • A specialist follows up within one business day
  • A no-obligation conversation about your specific goals
  • Answers from someone who actually works in this space
  • Your information stays confidential
Certified PartnerSOC 2 CertifiedHIPAA ReadyEnterprise Ready

Schedule a Free Consultation